P J Jewelers in Middletown, CT Closed now

Reviews about P J Jewelers

• ★ ★ ★ ★ ★

  March 01, 2020, by Christopher German
  I wish there were a few more stars because Five isn't enough. We had some tough choices to make about some closely held family related items that we were looking to appraise for resale. John and staff looked at our collection and right away knew what he was looking at and the experience just got better from there. He carefully went through our items and informed us what was of value and what was "recyclable". The thing that got me was not how he treated us, although it was wonderful, but how he treated the other customers. While we were there, a young woman came in with some sterling items she wanted to have a quick appraisal for personal purposes. John examined her items and while they were not Rodeo Drive quality, he respectfully and knowledgeably informed her that her items were of value, even if they didn't yield a boat load of cash. She didn't sell but she did walk away with an understanding that while her treasures would not be found in Donald Trump's home, they were of value and she was an important customer. We stopped at one of the chain stores prior to visiting John at PJ's and were told our items were junk and valued at less than $200. John looked at the lot of our items and gave us $1000 Plus. Holy More than we expected Batman! All levity aside, John is knowledgeable, his staff friendly and accommodating, his shop is secure and his location is in the heart of Connecticut's Jewelry District in picturesque downtown Middletown. I can't gush enough about our experience and if you think you want to get some cash for gold, need a special item for the special someone or just want an expert opinion about some of your jewelry, PJ Jewelers is the place to go. Please listen to me when I say this- they are Connecticut's BEST HUMAN Jewelry Store.
• ★ ★ ★ ★ ★

  February 15, 2019, by T Kup
  The people running this store are soooo nice!! Very helpful, knowledgable and fun! I have reccomended PJ’s to a lot of people and they always have a great experience. Especially when it involves an engagement ring. They will change your watch batteries, clean your items no charge and all with a smile. Its the happiest jewelery store i have ever been in... actually the happiest store experience I’ve known. I checked my purchases and in addition to feeling I paid a fare price, the prices always checked out.